Extra: Pitfalls of Modern Medical Training and the Dr/Primary Care Shortage
Renegade PsychMay 03, 2024x
8
33:5431.02 MB

Extra: Pitfalls of Modern Medical Training and the Dr/Primary Care Shortage

Join us for this episode outlining modern medical training and discussing some of the medicine cultural issues that contribute to a lack of critical thinking, and the primary care shortage, which is the worst in the world, by a landslide. Only 11.5% of U.S. Medical graduates go into primary care, which easily ranks as the lowest in the world (Germany is ~25%), and creates a system of specialists, typically without a capable general practitioner that is able to manage the entirety of your care. As David Healy told me, if you follow the guidelines for ADHD, and you follow the guidelines for bipolar, and you follow the guidelines for hypertension and headaches, you'll end up on a countless number of medicines, and we need intelligent and conscientous primary care providers to be able to provide good counsel to patients on the interactions of all these medications, and ultimately, reduce the polypharmacy epidemic we're seeing in our country and around the world today.

Joining me for the discussion today is Ariel Blythe-Reske, MD and psychiatrist working in NYC. I trained with Ariel and she is very intelligent, a good critical thinker, and high-energy and eccentric, with a lot of passion for her patients and providing good medical and psychiatric care. Our discussion is a little more informal, so beware if you don't like cursing or sarcasm... hope you enjoy.

Thanks for listening. For more social media content, check us out on all social media platforms @Renegadepsych. If you have any comments, questions or challenges to the information we've presented here, if you'd like to be a guest to the show, or if you have general comments, questions, or suggestions, email us at Renegadepsych@gmail.com and follow the link https://renegade-psych.podcastpage.io/ to our website for source material, transcripts, and additional links for my guests. If you feel passionate about our message and what we're trying to do, and you'd like to donate, you can also follow the link in the show notes to our website.

Disclaimer, this podcast is for informational purposes only. The information provided in this podcast and related materials are meant only to educate. This information is not intended as a substitute for professional medical advice. While I am a medical doctor and many of my guests have extensive medical training and experience, nothing stated in this podcast nor materials related to this podcast, including recommended websites, texts, graphics, images, or any other materials should be treated as a substitute for professional medical or psychological advice, diagnosis or treatment. All listeners should consult with a medical professional, licensed mental health provider or other healthcare provider if seeking medical advice, diagnosis, or treatment.

[00:00:00] Howdy Howdy. Today we're going to talk a little bit more about medical training, kind of outline

[00:00:05] the path to becoming a physician and talk about some of the cultural problems associated with

[00:00:12] medical school and residency. We'll talk a little bit about the cost, a little bit about the

[00:00:18] primary care shortage that we see in the United States, which is the worst of any country

[00:00:24] in the world by a lot. This is also one of the first recordings that we did with Rob,

[00:00:32] my audio engineer and friend. So you'll hear him a little bit on the discussion as well as

[00:00:38] a good friend of mine and former co-resident Ariel Blythresky. She is a delight to be around,

[00:00:46] is very intelligent, high energy, eccentric, cares a lot about her patients, has a really

[00:00:51] good bedside manner and is a good critical thinker, which is much needed in the field of psychiatry.

[00:00:58] Her and I together are maybe a little bit unhinged at times, but it should make for an

[00:01:04] interesting discussion. And if you like this more informal discussion format,

[00:01:10] please reach out to us, let us know at Renegade Psych on all social media platforms

[00:01:15] or RenegadePsych at gmail.com. Hope you enjoy. Somebody get this guy some help.

[00:01:31] Let's just kind of outline in a little bit more depth the path to becoming a physician

[00:01:36] in the United States. In your undergraduate years, you've got to pick a major. Usually it's

[00:01:42] something like a pre-medical or biology or chemistry, building a resume, trying to make

[00:01:48] some connections within the field. And you're preparing for the MCAT, which is the intro

[00:01:54] to medical school test, eight or nine hour test. If you're lucky enough to get entrance into

[00:01:59] medical school, you do roughly two years that are focused more on academic and you're just

[00:02:05] head in the book learning everything there is to know. And then you do two more years

[00:02:09] of clinical work where you're on the wards, you're in the hospital, you're in the clinic

[00:02:15] all the while you're taking tests for everything, tests on tests on tests. You can only fail a

[00:02:20] couple of them within your medical school. You're taking national standardized exams,

[00:02:26] step one and step two. You have to pass those to continue moving along in the process.

[00:02:33] Then in your fourth year, you start doing all these interviews and figure out where you

[00:02:37] want to spend the next four years doing your residency. Orders are $1,600, $1,700, but you've

[00:02:44] got to get it. Boards are $1,600? You've got to get a prep course along with it. But you spent

[00:02:50] like $3,000 on tests before you started making money. This is coming out of negative money.

[00:02:56] For step two, did you have to go to another city? I did step two. Yes. So you did. I went to LA.

[00:03:03] So after your third year at medical school, you have the standardized test at step two,

[00:03:07] nine hour multiple choice test. And then they used to make you go to one of five different cities

[00:03:15] in the country. You had to travel there and you see 12 different standardized patients or fake

[00:03:22] patients. And they all give you a grade. And you have to pass that too. And that was like

[00:03:27] a $1,200 thing. The test alone and the plane ticket, the hotel, you had to pay for all people took

[00:03:34] loads of drinks afterwards. Well, obviously that's another $1,200. At least how much time do you have

[00:03:41] to get a job outside of medical school? None. I tried to have a job five, 10 hours a week,

[00:03:48] but then I failed my first two tests. Oh my God. First two anatomy tests. So medical schools

[00:03:52] make you sign a contract that you're not allowed to have a position outside of med school.

[00:03:57] And even if you wanted to, there's no time because of all the me turn into a rote memorization machine.

[00:04:04] That's your full-time job. Residency is anywhere from three years for something like family medicine

[00:04:10] or emergency medicine up to seven years. If you want to be a neurosurgeon, you've got to take

[00:04:15] another what's called a step exam or a national standardized test. You got all kinds of performance

[00:04:21] reviews. You got to keep studying, keep expanding your knowledge. And then when you finally hopefully

[00:04:27] graduate from your residency program and don't fuck anything up for that four-year period,

[00:04:33] hopefully then you pass your boards to where you are now an officially certified psychiatrist or

[00:04:40] family doctor, etc., etc. If you are a primary care physician, you're talking about at least

[00:04:45] 11 years. If you are a neurosurgeon, you're talking about 15 years. Then there's fellowships on top

[00:04:53] of that. If you want to be the guy who takes out some rare gallbladder tumor or treats some rare

[00:05:01] pancreatic cancer or something, then it's another couple of years doing that exclusively.

[00:05:06] And then you have to take tests every 10 years. A lot of the European countries when

[00:05:13] people want to go into medicine, they will go to college and start their medical track.

[00:05:18] A lot of them started med school outside of high school and did six to seven years of

[00:05:23] dedicated medical training as opposed to our four years of horseshit. One entire year of basic

[00:05:30] sciences where we learned the crap cycle multiple times. And I've saved a lot of lives with that.

[00:05:36] And then just really two dedicated years of learning medicine for real.

[00:05:43] That's the problem where you do two years of just your heads in a book.

[00:05:47] And that stuff's important. Answering multiple choice questions is important

[00:05:51] because you do have to exhibit that you can retain a bunch of information and pull it out

[00:05:56] when you need it. And learning biochemistry is important if you want to know how the

[00:05:59] medications work. I think it's easier to remember mechanisms of action that become

[00:06:04] relevant to you and your practice if you know the biochemistry behind them. But you're never

[00:06:10] going to use the steps of gluconeogenesis or glycolysis. Why can't there be a little bit more

[00:06:17] balance in those first couple of years of school? You're going to do four weeks of head in the

[00:06:21] book and memorizing information, but then you're going to do a week or two where you're

[00:06:26] in the hospital. You're working on some service that is relevant to what you've been learning

[00:06:30] and you are actually providing something to that team that they've probably all forgotten.

[00:06:36] You learned through experience. You touched on not even knowing that I wanted to touch on it

[00:06:42] is this rote memorization. Find the right answer, be able to pick A, B, C, D or E on a multiple choice

[00:06:49] exam enough times. Wish life were multiple choice at this point because that's how I think

[00:06:55] anymore. I understand the point of rote memorization to a degree, but having been to medical school,

[00:07:03] I know I was never dumber and less interesting than when I was in medical school because as

[00:07:10] you're aware what they teach you how to do is regurgitate facts and not necessarily critically

[00:07:18] think. Medical school turns out all these cookie cutter doctors who have a lot of facts,

[00:07:26] but don't really know how to use them and don't know how to think. It's so frustrating and I

[00:07:31] number among those physicians you have to relearn how to think critically. I think layered onto

[00:07:37] that just imagine back in first year of medical school and you're sitting in class and the

[00:07:43] professor's talking about something that you don't fully understand, but you're in this ultra

[00:07:48] competitive. Everybody is so smart and they want to let you know how smart they are and so how

[00:07:54] comfortable did you feel raising your hand to ask a dumb question? Also for a woman who probably

[00:08:01] has an anxiety disorder I have to preface every question I ask with this might be a stupid

[00:08:06] question. You don't want to come off stupid but if you don't want to come off stupid not

[00:08:10] knowing that you come off stupid. You're constantly in this dick measuring contest with other physicians

[00:08:17] if you did not ever have a dose of humility you would in med school and you would learn that

[00:08:23] humility is a suppository. And so you get two kinds of physicians. You get people who were so

[00:08:32] stampeded by the system that they are apologetic and have so little confidence

[00:08:38] and then you get people who are the opposite. They're completely unapologetic because they need

[00:08:44] to project this air of total confidence in order to feel like someone who knows what they're doing.

[00:08:51] They have to project that they do but they don't take any input and so you get these ultra competitive

[00:08:57] shutting every other opinion out physicians. It closes doors it closes so many doors for

[00:09:02] your own understanding and your own growth. The medical training of course it's essential

[00:09:08] to your development as a physician you have to get it. There's so much information that you

[00:09:13] learn in med school that you need to know but if you were going to be a good doctor you were

[00:09:18] going to do it despite your medical training because your medical training it teaches

[00:09:22] you what you need to know to be a good doctor not how to be a good doctor. It breeds this

[00:09:27] desire to have the right answer. You spend so much time taking tests not just the five or six national

[00:09:35] standardized exams that you got to take but all your tests within your medical school and

[00:09:40] undergraduate so it really gets drilled in. Find out how to pick the right answer of these

[00:09:45] four to six options for every question. It's like a whole different game in its own.

[00:09:51] Yeah and so you do that for eight years maybe ten years and then you start seeing patients

[00:09:58] and it's like you're ingrained in this philosophy of I've got to find the right answer here but

[00:10:04] we're talking about human beings. We're talking about like super complex organisms. One of the

[00:10:09] reasons that we thrive is because we are so diverse every human being is like a snowflake

[00:10:16] unique and different and that carries with it a lot of evolutionary benefit if

[00:10:23] some virus comes through and hits us hard then it's not going to kill everybody because everybody's

[00:10:29] immune systems work a little bit differently. This system prioritizes knowing the right answer.

[00:10:35] It's a whole different like learning the answer they want to pick versus finding the answer

[00:10:40] in a person they don't necessarily like correlate. Right and if you come into the doctor and

[00:10:45] you're like oh I have this headache and then a little bit nauseous and I just try to find the

[00:10:52] right answer. If I miss it on the test then you know that's one point that I missed on the test

[00:10:57] but if I miss it in the context of your life then the consequences are a little bit more severe.

[00:11:04] The number of doctors that come out every year is a relatively stable and predictable number

[00:11:11] because there's only so many medical schools that have so many positions available.

[00:11:17] The bigger thing is there's only so many residency slots. That is when you're finished you graduate

[00:11:23] medical school and you go through this whole match process to try to find a place that matches with

[00:11:30] you. So the match occurs in March. You apply in your fourth year of medical school you send

[00:11:36] out a bunch of applications. You get letters of recommendation you send in all your test scores

[00:11:42] then around September, October they send out an interview request to you. Hey you want to come

[00:11:49] to Boston? They used to be all in person adding to the amount of money that you have to spend

[00:11:55] for flights and hotel and most of the residency programs don't cover you.

[00:12:02] Everybody's been interviewed by a bunch of programs. All the residency programs have a

[00:12:07] rank list. All the graduating medical students have a rank list and then this computer algorithm

[00:12:14] just goes ham and matches everybody to their program. It's a fucking computer? Yeah it's

[00:12:21] based on the rank list. If you had Yale as your number one school and Yale has nine spots

[00:12:29] and you're the tenth person and the other nine all wanted to go to Yale then you would not be able

[00:12:34] to go to Yale. That's the simplest way to describe it. All right so there's three different types of

[00:12:40] graduates that will apply for these positions. International foreign medical graduates people

[00:12:46] who went to what are called DO schools more homeopathic type of medicine more holistic

[00:12:53] but have the same amount of training as MDs. The American graduates do pretty well.

[00:12:59] The DOs and the MDs 85 to 95 percent match of the foreign medical graduates. This could be somebody

[00:13:06] who has already completed medical training in another country and is practicing there.

[00:13:12] They're right around 50 percent. Let me give you some numbers here. So 21, 2021 and 2022

[00:13:19] you had about 85,000 medical school graduates and they applied for 71,500 first year residency

[00:13:28] positions. So right there you've got a surplus of people who could enter into a residency position

[00:13:36] of 13,500. You've already got the people who want to pursue it and again a lot of those are

[00:13:44] international medical graduates but you're still talking about it roughly a thousand

[00:13:48] US graduates who have gone through the whole system in the United States and jumped through all the

[00:13:53] hoops and stuff. So that's 84 percent of medical school graduates who by the way have an average

[00:14:00] debt of 200 to 250,000 dollars match into a residency position. If you take out IMGs you're

[00:14:08] still talking about six to 10 percent of United States MD and DO graduates that don't enter into a

[00:14:15] residency position once they graduate. The number of residency spots that are funded primarily

[00:14:22] through what's called GME or Graduate Medical Education which is funded by Medicare and

[00:14:29] a little bit of the Veterans Affairs or the VA they control the number of residency positions.

[00:14:36] So literally every year there are thousands of students who don't match into a residency position.

[00:14:46] So then they made it all that way and they're just like well fuck?

[00:14:50] Yeah if they made it to that spot where they actually graduated medical school,

[00:14:54] they passed all their standardized exams, they did well enough in their classes to pass those

[00:14:59] actual medical school tests. You could end up not having a place to continue your more relevant

[00:15:07] clinical training and all it would take is to expand the number of funded positions.

[00:15:16] In the 70s and 80s the government was worried about a doctor surplus.

[00:15:21] A doctor surplus? Yeah. Hilarious. They're worried that there was gonna be too many

[00:15:25] docs and then for docs to be able to make the amount of money that they would need to make to

[00:15:29] offset the costs of school and residency, they would be doing all these unnecessary procedures

[00:15:35] and necessary tests and killing people for their organs. Exactly. That quickly fell out

[00:15:42] of popular opinion. We realized that we don't have nearly enough primary care docs to service

[00:15:47] our population. In 1997 this act passed in Congress called the Balance Budget Act and

[00:15:53] because Congress and the federal government subsidizes 90 something percent of the residency

[00:16:00] positions, in order to balance the budget they said no more increase in residency positions

[00:16:06] year over year for the next at least five years. Even though our population continues to increase.

[00:16:13] 2007 Congress put out this bill called the National Resident Physician Shortage Act.

[00:16:21] We don't have enough doctors to treat our population so we're gonna try to push this

[00:16:27] bill through that's gonna add 15,000 residency positions over a five year period. Start to

[00:16:33] address the problem. Well election cycle comes and goes and then all of a sudden that 2007

[00:16:40] National Resident Physician Shortage Act just kind of disappears doesn't get signed into law.

[00:16:46] A couple years later there's the second edition of the National Resident Physician Shortage Act

[00:16:54] and the exact same thing happens. There have been 12 or 13 of these acts nothing ever happens with

[00:17:01] them. They all propose to increase the number of residency positions to meet the shortage.

[00:17:08] They know how many we need over what period of time and then it fizzles out right after

[00:17:14] the election cycle. Yeah like every promise that requires money. Exactly it's literally just a scheme

[00:17:20] to help with reelection. Hey look at what we're doing. Only recently did anything get done. The

[00:17:27] one from 2021 didn't get passed. The only thing that's happened is there was another bill

[00:17:32] that gave us a thousand more residency positions just like a one-time thing. That's not nearly

[00:17:39] enough. Obviously the financial impact excludes a huge proportion of people that might want to do

[00:17:45] medicine, might be smart enough to do medicine and most importantly I think have the right mindset

[00:17:51] or the right reason for being there. There's an even more pressing problem in terms of what people

[00:18:00] who graduate from medical school do after that. This was staggering to me. You take 100

[00:18:06] physicians who graduate from medical school in the United States there will be roughly 12 of those

[00:18:12] who go into primary care. The person who's supposed to have an understanding of your whole health and

[00:18:18] well-being. I'm not surprised that's why there's a primary care shortage and that's why they're

[00:18:25] trying to bridge the shortage with mid levels whether they be MPs or PAs. The second lowest

[00:18:31] number is 23 percent in Germany. It's pretty tragic. 2.6 physicians in the United States per

[00:18:39] 1,000 people. If you break that down even further 0.3 primary care physicians for 1,000 people if

[00:18:46] everyone was to see an MD or a DO as their primary care doc those primary care docs would have to

[00:18:52] be seeing 3,300 patients a year but beyond that first I want to touch on how the culture within

[00:19:02] medical school treats people who want to do primary care. I went to University of Minnesota

[00:19:08] one of the top 10 schools in the country for recruiting primary care physicians. There was

[00:19:12] a lot of encouragement to go into primary care and a few people that I knew even had

[00:19:17] full-ride scholarships for people interested in primary care. The scholarship would pay

[00:19:23] as long as you were committed to a primary care specialty. That sounds like a solution.

[00:19:28] It is a solution. What was the attitude at UofL? It was like oh you want to do primary care,

[00:19:34] you're not very cool, no no no the cool kids are doing primary care and you must not be very

[00:19:39] smart. Okay that's so interesting that was not my experience really because of where I went

[00:19:44] to school and because of what they're trying to do is recruit more people. So I think the school

[00:19:48] attracted more people who are interested in primary care. Yeah we graduated more primary

[00:19:53] care doctors so because you went to a school that did not encourage matching in a primary care

[00:19:58] residency I'm interested to hear why you think people don't go. My guess is primarily the

[00:20:06] money for people who don't know primary care specialties are among the worst paid. I

[00:20:10] think pediatrics is by far the least compensated and again it sounds really insensitive if you're

[00:20:15] hearing this as someone who's not a physician to hear a physician say these doctors don't make much

[00:20:22] money but for the amount of education. And again I'm excluding teachers and social workers,

[00:20:29] you guys are excluded from this because you go through a ton of education and you get paid

[00:20:33] jack shit. You get paid jack shit exactly. For people who went through 11 or 12 years of education

[00:20:40] they get paid very poorly. I don't think that's the case in other countries that don't get

[00:20:45] compensated as well for specialties as they do in the United States. Yeah and you're talking about

[00:20:52] being very realistically a million dollars behind from where you could be. In Minnesota which

[00:20:59] where I went to med school I heard a statistic that by the age of 60 the average family medicine

[00:21:06] physician will be worth as much as the average teacher. In a state that is one of the best in

[00:21:13] the country for physician compensation. The remaining number like not going into primary care

[00:21:19] were they doing. In the United States everybody specializes it's usually a little bit longer

[00:21:25] training but there's more money. So it's kind of like you've come that far you might as well do

[00:21:31] the other couple years to specialize in something and it's well worth it financially because you're

[00:21:37] fucking a million dollars in debt. The shortage lies in primary care. Drastic shortage. I remember

[00:21:44] starting medical school there were maybe 120, 130 people in my class and 40 of them that were

[00:21:51] going to be orthopedic surgeons. Yeah yeah. And another dozen who are going to be neurosurgeons.

[00:21:56] Emergency medicine was tits when I was going to school. OB attracted a lot of people. Yeah

[00:22:04] Orthopods are everywhere. Orthopods are everywhere. Yeah and the orthopods are those jacked guys who

[00:22:08] are getting up at 5 a.m. to go work out. Honestly I knew one guy in my class who was interested

[00:22:14] in orthopedics and he was one of the best students in our class who like gave a shit.

[00:22:18] He probably couldn't bench press very much then. Add your step one score to your bench press and it's

[00:22:23] got to be over 500. So what are you bench man? So you better either be really smart or you better

[00:22:30] be jacked. Those are your options. Yeah that's correct. When you are in medical school you're

[00:22:36] talking about a bunch of Taipei people who've always gotten the best grades and been the

[00:22:41] smartest. You put them all together. Bunch of egos. What do you think people talk about

[00:22:46] going into in their first couple of years of medical school? What would you want to be?

[00:22:51] Fucking surgeon. Right I want to be an orthopedic surgeon. Oh I get what you're saying. The ego and

[00:22:57] like why would you sell yourself short and say I'm gonna be a primary care person. Yeah you've

[00:23:01] got this whole environment that is all about getting high test scores, knowing the right answer

[00:23:10] and in terms of like standardized national exams that all the medical students across the country

[00:23:17] take you get a score. When you go into residency years later these scores really matter. In order to

[00:23:26] do orthopedic surgery you better be in that 70th, 80th, 90th percentile of test scores.

[00:23:34] That produces this ultra competitive atmosphere and nobody's competing for the primary care spots.

[00:23:41] Oh it's like fucking playing baseball and being like I want to play for the

[00:23:45] Louisville bats when I grow up. Right even though in reality if you're talking about

[00:23:49] who is going to make the biggest impact on somebody's life? Primary care. Primary care

[00:23:55] absolutely. Intellectually you can see a bunch of different stuff, treat a bunch of different

[00:24:01] conditions. You can be like the old time doctors or critically think about something, use all this

[00:24:08] knowledge that they have but not in a memorized way. This is all obviously driven by like future

[00:24:15] salary for the most part unless you're very passionate about it. It's not just money

[00:24:20] though it's also the prestige. In your fourth year of medical school you have what's called

[00:24:26] match day where everybody figures out if they match into a residency spot and where at the same time

[00:24:32] which is kind of wild. And that's like getting picked for the team. Exactly. Exactly. If I can show up in your names not on the sheet.

[00:24:39] Yeah or you show up and it's like oh I got my 12th selection out of 13. I've got to go down to

[00:24:48] bumfuck Kansas and do primary care. It's put us in this situation in our country where

[00:24:54] we're graduating all these doctors not even enough doctors but we're all specialists. Yeah 89% of us are

[00:25:03] in some specialty. There is so much prestige attached to becoming an orthopedic surgeon or

[00:25:10] a neuro radiologist, a pediatric oncologist. There's so many people that want to do those

[00:25:17] things and there's limited numbers of spots for those. So there's a lot of people who don't

[00:25:21] match into those more specialized positions. Then there's what's called the supplemental match

[00:25:27] or the soap. This week period all these residency programs that didn't fill spots

[00:25:34] are reaching out to you because they know you're in the match but that you didn't match in any of

[00:25:39] those specialties. So most of those positions are going to be in primary care and unless

[00:25:44] you're willing to go into primary care where you will almost assuredly find a spot to

[00:25:49] scramble into your other option is to wait until the next year and figure out something to do in

[00:25:55] that year between that will build your resume or connect you to some specific program. There's

[00:26:01] a lot of people just doing it almost against their will that are even doing it like nobody

[00:26:05] wants to fucking do this. Exactly competitively who is landing in those positions? The people

[00:26:12] that don't want to be there and the people who generally had bad test scores or bad interviews

[00:26:18] or just bad candidates. You don't have the people even if they maybe like inherently really want to

[00:26:25] be the old timey family doctor they wanted to do that and then they get to medical school

[00:26:30] and for four years they're kind of told without being told this only people who couldn't match

[00:26:35] into these other more prestigious positions going to primary care. Yeah it's prestigious to talk

[00:26:42] about but if they were paying less then I don't know that we would still have the perception that

[00:26:48] they were so prestigious even though it's a specialized. I mean if you think about it these

[00:26:53] guys are one trick ponies you know a lot about this one thing well the primary health guy needs to

[00:26:58] know a lot about everything yes so that's like a more valuable. On a societal level absolutely

[00:27:05] always think about what if there was an apocalypse nobody really cares if you're really good at

[00:27:11] taking out a hankerous and avoiding the common bile duct and not nicking the aorta and I don't

[00:27:18] want the guy that's only been you know looking at baby dicks for in 10 years or do I want the guy

[00:27:24] that's seen it all had more for that guy everybody needs a primary health care everyone needs their

[00:27:30] you know their doctor. They picked out one year of all ambulatory care visits which is just

[00:27:36] anytime that you go out somewhere to get care whether it's in a clinic or a hospital 50% of

[00:27:43] them are primary care related problems and yet we only have 11% of us that go into primary care.

[00:27:50] How can you incentivize people to do what we need them to do? That is part of the solution

[00:27:57] This is the average BMI of the patient population in Bowling Green Kentucky and this is the average

[00:28:06] BMI of your patients. This was the profile of this patient before they came to see you. This is the

[00:28:12] profile of this patient after they came to see you just like getting a general medical

[00:28:16] checkup or a general medical checkup. This is the average BMI of your patients. This was the

[00:28:23] profile of this patient after they came to see you just like getting a general health screening.

[00:28:28] You are likely to have prevented some outcome therefore government will incentivize you in

[00:28:35] some way as opposed to the way that our system works now which is hey we'll incentivize you

[00:28:41] for seeing as many people as you can in the allotted amount of time and you just prescribe

[00:28:45] them all an oral and send them out of the way. Exactly so I guess we conclude that

[00:28:51] medical school in the United States is flawed in a lot of ways. It should be more experiential.

[00:28:56] It should encourage critical thinking, overwrote memorization. We didn't even talk about that

[00:29:02] like in terms of how you could test that. Even just having a multiple choice test and having

[00:29:07] the ability to ask questions about a question will show how much you know or don't know. I don't

[00:29:12] know how we change this or if it's possible or if every other country has the same culture

[00:29:18] as we do but the culture of medicine where you are not allowed to not know and you cannot

[00:29:25] demonstrate, you cannot betray ignorance which lends itself to either just a complete lack of

[00:29:33] confidence or a facade of overconfidence that is dangerous. We need to be able to ask questions

[00:29:41] without being made fun of or disregarded. You go to your doctor, you want your doctor to know

[00:29:48] what they're doing but I think I have more respect for a practitioner who tells me that

[00:29:52] they don't know but they'll figure it out than somebody who tells me that they know and they

[00:29:56] actually don't. This is reflected in medical school culture probably adopted from society in general.

[00:30:05] People have very high expectations for their physicians that they need to be acting a certain

[00:30:10] way, that they need to wear some tweed or something. They need to look professional. They

[00:30:15] can't have tattoos. They can't have colored hair. They need to look a specific way and they need to

[00:30:21] always comport themselves in a specific way and they can't fucking swear

[00:30:26] and they need to know and dedicate their lives to knowledge and not do anything else and that

[00:30:32] makes for a person that nobody wants to be around and nobody wants to take it. Nobody

[00:30:36] wants taking care of them. Yeah and none of that even touches on the impact that the industry

[00:30:43] has in our field and especially in America. We didn't ever talk about that. We didn't talk about

[00:30:48] having to document a certain way not in order to protect yourself legally. Definitely talked about

[00:30:54] that but in terms of making sure that shit gets paid for by the patient's insurance company,

[00:30:59] you are diagnosing them with the right condition not with what they actually have necessarily

[00:31:04] but with something that their insurance company will pay for. Yes. Will pay for the medicine.

[00:31:09] You got to have a certain number of symptoms described based on a diagnostic statistical manual

[00:31:16] that has been long ago debunked as not accurately portraying what mental illness is. Oh yeah.

[00:31:23] You've got big pharma reps who are coming in and educating you despite them having no clinical

[00:31:30] experience or education on how to use a medicine. And insurance is dictating

[00:31:35] what care you can or cannot provide for your patient. Yeah those are aspects that we need to

[00:31:42] have knowledge of before we get to our position where it makes you feel burnt out. It makes you

[00:31:46] feel like you cannot affect the system in a measurable way. It leads people to say I'm just going

[00:31:52] to be apathetic and what do you want? Oh you want a benzos or I don't care. You want a

[00:31:57] necessary eye. Okay yeah these are the side effects that I know about. I am going to tell

[00:32:02] you that this is going to help but I don't really know what's true about the long term.

[00:32:06] We've got to recognize like our role in these societal trends, our role in the opiate epidemic

[00:32:13] that started in medical school that saying we're under treating pain,

[00:32:16] the benzo epidemic up and down throughout the last 60 70 years because we're under

[00:32:22] treating anxiety etc etc. We need more government funding for residency positions. We've got

[00:32:28] to get people to go out into the rural community. We need people to go into primary care. Yas. We need

[00:32:33] more fucking humans to be in medicine. God bless but we need people. We need people. Not to Dr.

[00:32:41] Botts. Exactly not algorithms. Yes exactly. Somebody get this guy some help.

[00:32:57] Thanks for listening. For more social media content check us out on all social media

[00:33:01] platforms at Renegade Psych. If you have any comments, questions or challenges to the information

[00:33:05] we've presented here or if you'd like to be a guest of the show feel free to email us

[00:33:08] renegadesyke at gmail.com. Follow the link in the show notes to our website for source material,

[00:33:12] transcripts and additional links for my guests. And if you feel passionate about our message

[00:33:16] and what we're trying to do and you'd like to donate you can also follow the link in the

[00:33:19] show notes to our website. Thank you. Disclaimer this podcast is for informational purposes only.

[00:33:23] The information provided in this podcast and related materials are meant only to educate.

[00:33:26] This information is not intended as a substitute for professional medical advice.

[00:33:29] While I am a medical doctor and many of my guests have extensive medical training and experience.

[00:33:32] Nothing stated in this podcast nor materials related to this podcast, including recommended

[00:33:36] websites, texts, graphics, images or any other materials should be treated as a substitute for

[00:33:40] professional medical or psychological advice diagnosis or treatment. All listeners should

[00:33:43] consult with a medical professional licensed mental health provider or other healthcare

[00:33:47] provider if seeking medical advice diagnosis or treatment or put more simply need help like

[00:33:51] this guy. Call your own doctor.